Coincidental Destinies

Tunnel-sniffing revolution on Gaza`s last frontline 

youth on hill
photo 1

13th January, CAIRO (AFP) – From radar to fibre optics and sonar to sweat, the quest to find an efficient method of unearthing Gaza`s smuggling tunnels has become crucial to achieving a truce in the beleaguered territory.

 

children with donkey cart on empty street
photo 2

The United States has promised Egypt 33 million dollars (25 million euros) of equipment to detect the tunnels which Israel says are used to smuggle weapons, including the rockets that are regularly fired at Israel, as well as food and medicine. 

boy with ball on empty street
photo 3

And while Israel says it will not halt its offensive until it has guarantees that tunnel smuggling will end, neither the US nor Egypt will answer questions about what techniques are being used along the 14-kilometre (nine-mile) border. 

2 school girls on empty street
photo 4

The Nazis buried microphones to detect POW escape attempts, while Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) invented by the US to combat Viet Cong tunnels has been further developed by archaeologists in their quest for the secrets of the past. 

2 boys in front of wall with bullet holes
photo 5

Such methods, as well as more bizarre techniques such as sniffing around for human sweat, have remained favourites of tunnel busters from Mexico to Northern Ireland. 

lingering male youth in front of closed shops
photo 6

Lawrence Conyers of the University of Denver says that GPR -- in this case dragging a radar behind a moving vehicle -- is the best tunnel detecting technology, especially for the sandy type of soil on the Egypt-Gaza border. 

2 small boys running on sandy street
photo 7

“But it`s not like turning on a metal detector and having it `beep` when it finds things,” he told AFP. “Data processing and interpretation are needed.” 

boys and girls on sandy street
photo 8

He says that it can be difficult to tell the difference between the top and the bottom of a tunnel using radar techniques. 

teenaged girl carrying shopping bag
photo 9

“Sometimes the radar energy gets into the void space and bounces around a good deal before coming back to the surface, which makes it very complicated.” 

2 small children playing between houses with bullet holes
photo 10

Egyptian soldiers have reportedly been trained to use the US equipment, but, says Conyers, “it takes someone who has a real interest in doing it, they must make it more than just a `soldier`s job`.” 

2 teeneged girls walking through construction sites
photo 11

The soldier must learn how to collect the data while dragging the device behind a truck travelling at 20 miles per hour (30 kilometres per hour) and “take it on a laptop and process it and then spend time looking hard at it.” 

6 young women walking on empty street
photo 12

Conyers dismisses other tunnel busting methods such as sonar, magnetics, resistivity, electromagnetic induction as inferior to GPR. 

young girls with green and white Hamas ribbon around head
photo 13

Another technique, detecting tiny muon particles created by cosmic rays, is “wacky stuff and only just beginning to be understood,” he says. 

2 boys laughing
photo 14

But Israeli researchers have now developed a potentially revolutionary system which uses a fibre optic cable that can detect and identify the most minute soil movements -- and requires no expertise to operate. 

3 boys on a pick-up carrying Hamas flags
photo 15

“The advantage is that we can monitor 30 kilometres of fibre using only one computer and you don`t need to go along the border because it`s already buried underground,” says Dr Assaf Klar of Israel`s Technion, Institute of Technology. 

boy in a crowd carrying Palestinian flag
photo 16

“And it costs less than a few dollars per metre,” says Klar, who came up with the idea while doing research on the effects of building work on tunnels and pipelines in Britain. 

3 girls holding a framed photograph of a martyr
photo 17

“The major part of the research was the computer brain that can recognise that it`s a tunnel and not just traffic or a vehicle or rain, to distinguish the signal of the tunnel compared to other signals,” Klar told AFP. 

2 youngsters with Palestinian ribbon around their heads
photo 18

“It`s just a programme at the end and it will tell the soldier `I recognise a tunnel at this and this metre please go and check`. It`s very easy,” says Klar, adding that a working prototype could be ready in two months. 

young boy in uniform with Hamas ribbon pointing to the sky
photo 19

But what if a smuggler simply cuts the fibre optic cable? 

young boy with laughing at his funny bike
photo 20

“You can put two fences either side of the cable to protect it, but even if there`s no fence, the cable is buried one metre (three feet) down and you must start to excavate to reach it.” 

young boy with Hamas ribbon round his head
photo 21

“And once you do that the cable feels soil movement and it will alert that someone is excavating. Even if someone does manage to cut the cable then we know immediately exactly where it is and just splice it together again.” 

children crowd with Hamas hats
photo 22

But Klar admits that while his system is excellent for detecting the digging of new tunnels, it`s of little use against the hundreds that reportedly already exist on the border -- for them, old school GPR remains the best way to sniff.


 

2 tennaged girls making peace signs, in the background Fatah flags
photo 23


photographs 1-12 by Rayelle Niemann, Rafah, Gaza, May 2005
photographs 13-23 by Charles Onians, Gaza City, Gaza, June 2006
text by Charles Onians, Cairo, January 2009
 

top ]
  
Gaza - scattered mosaic
Coincidental Destinies
OTHER PROJECTS ON CITYSHARING
Accessible Approach
In the Shadow of the Pyramids
Moving on – Moving back – Moving on
Fragmented Letters
Reaching Boundaries
Palestinian Dictionary
What remains and Things to come
Due of high spam-traffic we decided to close the comment form
for the time being

FEATURED THEME ON CITY SHARING

EL MATAM EL MISH MASRY
by ASUNCION MOLINOS GORDO
-
This project is an instrument for common critical analysis to help understand the reasons behind Egyptians’ diminishing …

→ GO TO PROJECT

LETTERS TO FRITZ AND PAUL
by INAS HALABI
-
The project Letters to Fritz and Paul focuses on the expeditions of the Swiss cousins, lovers and scientists, Fritz and …

→ GO TO PROJECT

MODERN LEAVES
by SARAH BURGER
-
The planned modern city of Brasilia attracted me since a long time. Her defined shape, location and function proceded he …

→ GO TO PROJECT

CITRACIT
by ADRIEN GUILLET
-
Youri Telliug talks with the artist Adrien Guillet about his project Citracit

Youri Telliug - What is Citracit …

→ GO TO PROJECT

NARRATIONS OF FLIGHTS
by NIGIST GOYTOM
-
In 2013 more than 45 million people have been forced to leave their homes. This amounts to the biggest number of refugees …

→ GO TO PROJECT

A RUG - POST-ORIENTALISM
by SULAFA HIJAZI
-
The on going debate on Arab identity and its (cultural) representation is strongly shaped by Edward Saidʼs formative …

→ GO TO PROJECT

WAM _ WORLD AGRICULTURAL MUSEUM
by ASUNCION MOLINOS GORDO
-
WAM is a site-specific work that uses the historical trope of the cabinet of curiosities to explore the introduction of …

→ GO TO PROJECT

MORE CONTRIBUTIONS BY THE FOLLOWING

A
Akram Al Halabi ]
Atelier für Sonderaufgaben ]
B
Baggenstos/Rudolf ]
Basam Baroni and Jeremy Beaudry ]
Taysir Batniji ]
Hannes Brunner ]
Sarah Burger ]
C
Francisco Paco Carrascosa ]
D
Dector Dupuy ]
Erik Dettwiler ]
Ala’ Diab ]
Dlungwana & Gumbi ]
E
Egypt - 25th January ]
Sherif El-Azma ]
Shady El-Noshokaty ]
Mohamed Elshahed ]
Fawzy Emrany ]
F
forget 2 forget ]
Abrie Fourie ]
Anselmo Fox ]
G
Lamya Gargash ]
• Gaza - scattered mosaic •
A Gentil Carioca ]
Heiner Goebbels ]
Malak Gomaa ]
Nigist Goytom  ]
Adrien Guillet ]
H
Inas Halabi ]
Here I Stand ]
Sulafa Hijazi ]
I
Saba Innab ]
K
Ulrike Kuschel ]
L
Gabriela Löffel ]
Heinrich Lüber ]
Christin Lahr ]
Mariann Landolt ]
Jason Larkin ]
Björn Larsson ]
Yasser Abdel Latif ]
Emanuel Licha ]
Marcelo Lima ]
M
Made In Musina ]
Laura Martin ]
moddr_ ]
Naeem Mohaiemen ]
Asuncion Molinos Gordo ]
N
Mimi Cherono Ng’ok ]
Rayelle Niemann ]
Thenjiwe Niki Nkosi ]
No Condition is Permanent ]
O
Wouter Osterholt and Elke Uitentuis ]
P
Pilgrimages ]
Silvia Popp ]
R
Youssef Rakha ]
S
Raeda Saadeh ]
Lina Selander ]
Lerato Shadi ]
Bahia Shehab ]
stadt.labor ]
Vassiliea Stylianidou ]
Syria _ files ]
T
Treibsand ]
U
urbaninform ]
V
Laurence Vale ]
Costa Vece ]
W
Lee Wen ]
Z
Margot Zanni ]
Michel Zayat ]

 

INVITED-PROJECTS